22 Oct 2025

The Other Side of Reason: Carlos Amorales’ Social Modernism

Ein Bild von Carlos Amorales

BY MICHAEL SICINSKI

Like fellow iconoclasts Vito Acconci and Ai Weiwei, Carlos Amorales is a multimedia polymath. Based in Mexico City, where he was born, he previously studied at the Gerrit Rietveld Academy in Amsterdam, where he not only began exploring unconventional artistic media but also became fascinated with the ways in which the germ of a concept could blossom in entirely different ways, based on the forms and formats he applied to it. In addition to film and video, Amorales’ work has included live music and dance, body art, textiles and large-scale sculpture, all with the same broad concerns flowing across or shifting between them. First and foremost, Amorales’ oeuvre participates in and expands the traditions of Mexican modernism, drawing on various syncretic spiritual and mythic practices in order to subject them to critical scrutiny.

His 2015 film project EL NO ME MIRES, for example, brings revolutionary abstraction to bear on artisanal practices. In it, frequent collaborator Philippe Eustachon plays an Inuit seal hunter who has been subject to a sort of constructivist enchantment, whereby he becomes invisible to Europeans. The man fades into fragmented, solid-colour backgrounds that draw on Kasimir Malevich’s Soviet-era theories of universal formalism. To this end, Amorales combines responsive-eye optics—like those employed during World War II to disguise ships—and architecture, while at the same time alluding to the modernist mysticism of Joseph Beuys.

Filmstill of El hombre que hizo las cosas prohibidas
EL HOMBRE QUE HIZO LAS COSAS PROHIBIDAS (2014)

Conceptual riffing on the history of art is another motif in Amorales’ work. Like Beuys, the artist seeks to adapt the trajectories of modernism to forge a broader, more humanist project of reclamation. And like Beuys, Amorales sees the atelier as a laboratory, a space to test out social hypotheses as well as a site to explore irrational tendencies that might be destructive under other circumstances. Part of this project has to do with the adaptation of earlier aesthetic technologies in order to discover their hidden potentials.

His 2012 sculptural installation WE’LL SEE HOW ALL REVERBERATES thus rethinks the kinetic art object; must it move only on its own, according to the unpredictable currents of available air, or can it be deliberately set in motion by the viewer? For this work, Amorales adapted the mobiles of Alexander Calder but outfitted them with suspended cymbals, inviting the viewer to tap them in defiance of the typical no-touch regulations of the gallery space.

Amorales also employs compositional techniques that “rationalise” the irrational, treating natural or intuitive phenomena as the basis for high-formalist experimentation. His 2010 drawing exhibition VERTICAL EARTHQUAKE replicated the massive cracks in various buildings caused by the 1985 Mexico City earthquake. Those zigzagging gaps were fabricated into flat metal forms, which were then affixed to the gallery wall. From there, Amorales used these “broken rulers” as mechanical drawing machines, showing that despite their haphazard formations, they would ultimately etch predictable circular forms when spun. VERTICAL EARTHQUAKE is reminiscent of both the conceptual drawing projects of Sol LeWitt and the site-specific excavations of Robert Smithson or Gordon Matta-Clark, while also alluding to the palpable ways in which horrific crises are “smoothed out” and rendered legible in historical and political discourses.

Instead of adhering to tired dichotomies of traditional folkways versus Enlightenment, Amorales explores the vibrant contact zones in which different belief systems and life-worlds clash and mutually redefine each other. His film work is particularly well-suited to this approach, since his crisp, clear digital cinematography lends a contemporary veneer to images that partake of unruly irrationalism.

His 2013 project AMSTERDAM is a two-person cinematic performance that Amorales termed “a love story gone strange”. His two actors, Eustachon and Elsa-Louise Manceaux, operate in a preverbal world of wails, grunts, and wild gestures. With its chilly black-and-white cinematography, it resembles Philippe Garrel’s early surrealist films, but the physical actions of the two participants—who cover themselves with paint, writhe around in primal, Edenic nudity and push themselves to greater levels of intensity—shows the clear influence of the Viennese Actionists. The hi-hat cymbal, which is used as both percussion and a headgear in the film, refers back to WE’LL SEE HOW ALL REVERBERATES, putting the “sculpture” to work.

AMSTERDAM is also notable for the fact that its actors were provided with a visual collage “score” as opposed to a script. Images of the performers’ faces and bodies provided cues as to how they should react at any given moment in the film. AMSTERDAM follows the logic of Amorales’ so-called “Liquid Archive”, a digital collection of vector and fractal drawings that convey gestures and trajectories rather than specific motivations. This permits the artist to “compose” between artistic disciplines while retaining common ideas.

The subversive potential of the irrational
In this regard, Amorales seeks to map out the intangible pulsions that motivate his work, a paradoxical attempt to commit the irrational to a representable form. His 2014 featurette EL HOMBRE QUE HIZO TODAS LAS COSAS PROHIBIDAS represents a further exploration of the subversive potential of the irrational. The film was inspired by radical poetics movements in Chile that emerged in the wake of the 1973 coup against Salvador Allende. Following the logic of the Liquid Archive, Amorales arranges the film in two parts, each a different iteration of the same set of ideas, one explanatory, the other ritualistic. The first part is a conversation with Eustachon on Chilean talk radio, explaining the provenance of the piece. Then the “actual” film begins, a loping, often nonsensical journey through the woods by a top-hatted magician (also played by Eustachon) and three acolytes. Two of them are living, and one of them is dead, having been stabbed by the magician early on. The others nevertheless carry her shrouded corpse around, incorporating it into their childlike theatrics. Those with a background in experimental cinema will see echoes of the Baudelairean antics of Jack Smith and Ron Rice. EL HOMBRE QUE HIZO TODAS LAS COSAS PROHIBIDAS is a paean to the revolutionary potential of the unconscious.

Filmstill of El hombre que hizo las cosas prohibidas
EL HOMBRE QUE HIZO LAS COSAS PROHIBIDAS (2014)

Everything is permanently up for negotiation
But as Eustachon states in the interview in the prologue, this rupture is local and systematic. Amorales reminds us that Pinochet’s Chile was the first practical laboratory for the Chicago School’s neoliberal economic strategies. Part of this approach, as Naomi Klein and others have observed, is “disaster capitalism,” wherein a political faction sweeps in during a period of great unrest and offers “stability” in the form of massive privatisation and the cessation of civil rights. Seen from this perspective, Amorales looks to the “Ideological Cubists” of post-coup Chile as a model of disruption and ungovernability.

In a key scene from EL HOMBRE QUE HIZO TODAS LAS COSAS PROHIBIDAS the performers are in a forest clearing, and we see that the ground is crawling with beetles. At first, one of the performers picks up a large leafy branch and sweeps the ground with it, attempting in vain to remove the insects from the area. In a subsequent shot, Amorales has all four performers, each with their own multi-branched limb, sweeping in unison while doing a dance.

In a sense, this part of the film is a kind of inversion of Amorales’ 2007 installation work BLACK CLOUD, in which thousands of black paper moths are attached to the walls and ceiling, a sculptural infestation that also looks ahead to Ai Weiwei’s SUNFLOWER SEEDS (2010) a few years later. But this film sequence functions like a microcosm of Amorales’ aesthetic ethos. Nature exists in all its chaos. Humans try to control that chaos with an irrational gesture that takes on its own logic through repetition and replication until both order and chaos are sublated into an affective conundrum. Whether in the gallery space, on the stage, or on the screen, Amorales wants to ensure that nothing is static, and everything is permanently up for negotiation.